My favorite Cowboys & Indians party ideas and elements from this fantastic first birthday celebration are: The darling Cowboy and Indian banners made from ribbon tassels and burlap The cute drink bottles wearing cowboy hats and scarves The cute teepee table centerpieces The darling Sheriff and arrow in target sugar cookies The cute food labels and tags The cute cupcakes topped with plastic figurines/toys The cute teepee cake pops The cute muslin favor bags imprinted with cowboy and indian. 16 results for "cowboys and indians party supplies" Skip to main search results Eligible for Free Shipping. Free Shipping by Amazon. Western Party Decoration Supplies Western Masks Western Cowboy Masks Halloween Masks for Western Themed Party Costumes Photo Prop Dress Up, 10 Styles. out of 5 stars $ $ 8.